Sunday, September 12, 2010

Yay or Nay? Madame de Genlis

It was another Yay for haberdashery as Lady Taylor pulled in a victory for her high brimmed hat.  We have not seen what French couture has to offer in the realm of headgear. Perhaps we are overdue?


Adelaide Labille-Guiard paints Madame de Genlis (1780) in her bonnet of lace and ribbons.  Yay or Nay?

H.W. Blunt Collection

18 comments:

Lady Z said...

Nay, for the love of god! NAY!

French at hArt said...

It is a very prettily painted bow, but really, it doesn't belong on a human head! Nay...
Au Revoir,
♥Danette

heidenkind said...

It's a little... much. It looks like her head is being swallowed by the Lace Monster.

Nessa said...

Nay! You can't see anything but that BOW.

Cherylynn said...

Yay!----if she were a wedding present. Otherwise, nay.

The Duchess said...

I agree with Cherylynn. A big Nay! It is so...weird. Nay!

Charleybrown said...

I'm distracted by those green gloves! She looks like Elphaba! And the green clashes with the blue. The bow does make her look like she's meant to be someone's present!

Comtesse Olympe de la Tour D'Auvergne said...

Nay! I agree with Cherylynn, she looks like a wedding present. It is way too much everything.

Fabulastic said...

I am not so concerned with the bow: the biggger the better.

I think the gloves are the problem. The minute she goes out of that chair, the green gloves will clash with the blue dress.

Do you think it may be the painter that changed the gloves colour in order to balance the painting?

(by the way, I would love to know more about the paintings you post. Can you had some information underneath the picture?)

Audrey said...

Nay, just nay. It is so sad how ruffles can be abused.

Jessi P (AKA Emily Ryder) said...

Too much. Nay!

Jael said...

Well, I'm gonna say Yay! Go big or go home, I'm in agreement with Fabulastic. On her right side it looks like there's another bow on the back and I'm curious as to how many bows there are on there. I think those indoor bonnets would be irritating enough to wear, why not have some fun with it.

Miss Honnete said...

Lovely bow and those gloves are nice!! But together and arranged in such a way (speaking about the bow) are a fashion disaster. NAY!!

cindyj said...

Oo, my first vote! Definitely a nay. The last two hats were wonderful but that's a big ribbon and lace mess!

Patricia said...

Oh dear, it appears that Madamme got most of her looks from her father. The very masculine looking neckcloth does not help, or was she a cross-dresser? In any event, we are looking at the hat. The lace is lovely but the bow is...awkward. I will not speak of the green gloves. Nay.

Emmeline Cartwright said...

oh I missed Ms Taylor... Well Mdm de Genlis gets a huge YAY, especially for her gloves. I love them and all the colours of her attire.

Alisa said...

The lace ruffles in the wrong places, the dark colour and the loose fit of the dress and the powdered hair in a time when powder wasn't that common any more - all of that makes her looks like she's in her sixties when she wasn't even forty at the time of the portrait! What a granny look!

Alisa said...

Oops, I should add just in case it wasn't obvious from my rant: Nay.